Skip to main content

Game of Thrones recap: season 6, episode 9, Battle of the Bastards review: Jon and Sansa's bitter spat and Ramsay's brutal sacrifice



Game of Thrones season 6, episode 9, Battle of the Bastards
Game of Thrones season 6, episode 9, Battle of the Bastards CREDIT: HBO

Oh now, that was VERY impressive. And by “impressive” we mean gruelling, cathartic and upsetting. By the end of the Battle of the Bastards and the Jon Snow v Ramsay Bolton showdown over Winterfell we felt as if we’d crawled through a freezing quagmire, climbed a wall of cadavers and gasped for breath as a dozen dying men sat on our faces. Which, oddly enough, is exactly what befell Jon as the grumpy saviour negotiated the grandest mass battle Game of Thrones has yet mounted for our enjoyment/terror/disgust
Tormund Giantsbane in Game of Thrones season 6, episode 9, Battle of the Bastards
Tormund Giantsbane in Game of Thrones season 6, episode 9, Battle of the Bastards
A cast of hundreds, a budget of millions, flayed men roasting on an open fire – season four’s penultimate episode had it all. Yet spectacle took a backseat to gut-punch drama as poor, sweet Rickon met his untimely demise and questions were raised over the leadership qualities of Jon, rescued, at the death, by Sansa and her subterfuge. 
This was Game of Thrones at its finest – setting the scene for an epic clash, then subverting expectations with violence that seemed far too… violent, and a villain condemned to a death so horrific that, when it came to it, you felt slightly sorry for him. Next week's finale will clock in at an unprecedented 69 minutes – but how can it possibly top the topsy turvy excitement that unfolded here? 

1. The action was some of the best seen on the small screen 

Showrunners DB Weiss and David Benioff were true to their promise that the Battle of the Bastards would be unprecedented in sweep and ambition. With its mountains of corpses and up-close garrotings and beheadings, this was Braveheart spliced with the opening 20 minutes of Saving Private Ryan. 
Game of Thrones season 6, episode 9, Battle of the Bastards
Ser Davos Seaworth (Liam Cunningham) in Game of Thrones season 6, episode 9, Battle of the Bastards
It was also a repudiation of the idea that warfare is in any way “epic”. Here was a hellish tableaux of men clambering over dead comrades, warriors who had dreamed of a glorious end unceremoniously trampled in the muck. George RR Martin's novels are at their heart about the distance between myth and reality – in the Battle of the Bastards that thesis was spun into 20 minutes of visceral horror. More positively – likeable, decent Ser Davos survived! (we did not think likeable, decent Ser Davos would survive) 

2. Who cares that the twist was a cliché? 

Sansa Stark (Sophie Turner) and Jon Snow (Kit Harington) in Game of Thrones season 6, episode 9, Battle of the Bastards
Sansa Stark (Sophie Turner) and Jon Snow (Kit Harington) in Game of Thrones season 6, episode 9, Battle of the Bastards
Can you believe it? Just as all appeared lost, Sansa's secret reinforcements arrived in the shape of Littlefinger's Knights of the Vale. Surprise allies galloping over the hill has been a cliche since the heyday of the Western - yet you couldn’t help cheering. It was Sansa who, with guile and steely will, overcame Ramsay – not earnest, mud-spattered Jon. Hurrah! 

3. Ramsay's death was horribly poetic. And also, just horrible

Ramsay Bolton (Iwan Rheon) in Game of Thrones season 6, episode 9, Battle of the Bastards
Ramsay Bolton (Iwan Rheon) in Game of Thrones season 6, episode 9, Battle of the Bastards
Eaten by the very mastiffs he had unleashed on his baby brother all those weeks ago – and while Sansa watched, with cold, introspective satisfaction. Given Jon Snow’s importance, it was inevitable Team Stark would triumph at Winterfell but many of us had pictured Ramsay felled by a sword or stomped by a giant (yes, RIP Wun Wun!). Instead, Game of Thrones propped him in a chair and arranged for him to be ripped to pieces by the once loyal hounds he'd starved for seven days. 
As a side-note: what a relief Ramsay is at last gone. He was a fantastically cartoonish bad guy – but far too straightforwardly nasty for a show that has set itself against simple good v evil moralising.

4. The episode was really all about “Girl Power”

Game of Thrones has been justly criticised for employing young actresses as wobbly-wobbly window dressing and, though the toplessness has been dialled back this season, it’s still very much a calling card. However there are reasons for suspecting that the series is attempting to make amends – by arguing that Westeros would be far better off with women in charge. Even as Sansa was turning the tide at Winterfell, in Meereen Daenerys and Yara Greyjoy were striking up a lady bromance – and seemingly rock-solid alliance –  for the ages. They understood one another absolutely and had fun with their mild flirtation. From blizzards of boobs to a cogent argument for the matriarchy – my how you’ve changed Game of Thrones. 

5. Rickon's death was devastating – even if you’d basically forgotten about Rickon

To think we'd forgotten the youngest Stark was even still alive when the show dragged him from the basement earlier this season. But we suddenly, urgently cared for Rickon as Ramsay kicked off hostilities by cutting him down in view of the terrified teenager’s brother and sister. The battle was a tragedy before it had begun - an extraordinary piece of manipulation that caused the viewer’s blood to run cold even as the heart beat faster. 

6. Didn't the pre-fight banter fall a bit flat? 

Jon Snow (Kit Harington) in Game of Thrones season 6, episode 9, Battle of the Bastards
Jon Snow (Kit Harington) in Game of Thrones season 6, episode 9, Battle of the Bastards
You expected sparks as Ramsay and Jon Snow met for a preliminary natter. Alas, their zingers didn't quite land. It fell to Sansa – “Lady Bolton” as Ramsay insisted on calling her – to deliver the best line. "You 're going to die tomorrow Lord Bolton, sleep well.” 
Sansa has obviously been this year's breakout – her transformation into steely-eyed survivor forged in the white heat of her degradations at the hands of Ramsay. Jon has the swagger and the sword – but Sansa was the one with true vengeance in her gaze, a point Benioff and Weiss made with impressive forthrightness.

7. The real battle was the row between Sansa and Jon

In an episode brimming with eye-widening set pieces, the best moment was a simple conversation – okay a heated spat – between brother and sister. The show reminded us just how hardened Sansa had become as she told Jon that trying to rescue Rickon was pointless: he was dead already. Amid all the blood, thunder and mud (there was lots of mud – did they have to fly extra in?), this was one of the scenes that will stay with us. Is Game of Thrones not too subtly hinting Sansa, not Jon, would be the more fitting ruler? 
Wun Wun the giant in Game of Thrones season 6, episode 9, Battle of the Bastards
Wun Wun the giant in Game of Thrones season 6, episode 9, Battle of the Bastards

8. They're finally getting the dragons right

We've had our issues with Daenerys riding about on Fake Drogon this season. But as the Mother of Dragons’s favourite metaphorical offspring led his siblings on a triple threat pushback against the Masters, such concerns went up in flame. The show’s much vaunted FX team had for once delivered and it was genuinely stirring to see Daenerys perched imperiously on Drogon’s back as the invading fleet burned.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Hillary Clinton Gains Double-Digit Lead Over Donald Trump in Key Battleground States

Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton has built up a significant lead in several crucial battleground states, according to new NBC/WSJ/Marist polling released today. Clinton has generated double-digit margins in Virginia and Colorado with 13-point and 14-point advantages over Trump, respectively. The poll also showed Clinton with leads over Trump in Florida and North Carolina. In the Sunshine State, Clinton has a 5-point edge among registered voters. In North Carolina, Clinton enjoys a 9-point advantage. Losses in these states could be devastating for Trump. The Republican nominee’s clearest path to the White House requires wins in Ohio and Florida, where Hillary Clinton has a slight lead, as well as North Carolina and Pennsylvania, where he trails by a broad nine percentage points. Trump has been plagued by controversy since his party’s convention three weeks ago, clashing with the father of a fallen Muslim soldier, refusing to endorse House Speaker...

Ten Things I Wish I Knew When I Started 'Deus Ex: Mankind Divided'

Photo: Eidos Deus Ex: Mankind Divided  is finally out today, an early embargo revealing pretty solid reviews, including my own 8/10 good-not-great score. I love the series, but I just wanted the sequel to evolve a little more than it did. With that said, what it does carry over from  Human Revolution  is welcome, and I enjoyed my time with the game overall. As always, when I get to play a game this early, I try to impart wisdom I’ve learned for those who are just starting out. This is a game where you have to make a lot of fundamental choices about both the story and which upgrade path you pick, so it doesn’t hurt to get some early guidance. There’s a lot to say, but I’ve narrowed it down to a handful of points for your consumption. Here are the ten things I wish I knew when I started  Deus Ex: Mankind Divided : 1. There Are At Least Two Ways To Do Almost Anything Deus Ex: Mankind Divided , like its predecessor, is a game about choice. ...

Frank Ocean new album: How to listen and stream Boys Don’t Cry when it drops

After two missed release dates a year apart and a confusing decoy of a “live stream” video, Frank Ocean is set to finally release his second album,  Boys Don’t Cry , on Friday 5 August. It will be launched through an exclusive deal with Apple Music, according to the  New York Times , who cite a ‘person with knowledge of the release plans’. If indeed this is the case (and it would make sense, that live stream has an Apple watermark), it means you’ll need to sign up for Apple Music to listen to the  Channel Orange  follow-up, which costs £9.99 a month (£4.99 for students through Apple’s UNiDAYS promotion). You might want to turn off auto-renewal off though (Apple Music app > profile icon > View Apple ID. > Subscriptions > Manage > switch Auto-Renewal off), if you’re the kind of person who, like me, is liable to forget that you’ve signed up for the service indefinitely. Beyond Apple Music...